6 Best Sandwich Makers – Top Picks and Reviews for 2017

Last updated: 9th November 2017

Looking for the best sandwich maker? Read our in-depth sandwich maker reviews, comparison charts and top picks for 2017 to help you make the right buying decision for the perfect morning sandwiches.

If you love sandwiches — and who doesn’t — you might be looking for a faster, easier way to make them. Warm, toasted sandwiches can be made in just a few minutes with the use of special sandwich making appliances.

Sandwich makers let you fill your sandwiches with the ingredients that you want; after that, the sandwich maker does the cooking for you. Some sandwich makers can even make other foods, such as waffles. Here are some of the best options available in 2017, ranging from a simple sandwich toaster to a layered breakfast sandwich maker.

A summary of the best sandwich makers

  1. George Foreman GRP4842P Multi-Plate Evolve Grill/Sandwich Maker
  2. Hamilton Beach 25490 Dual Breakfast sandwich maker
  3. Hamilton Beach 25478 Breakfast sandwich maker
  4. T-Fal SW6100 EZ Non-Stick Sandwich Maker
  5. Proctor Silex 25401P
  6. Proctor Silex 25408 Sandwich Toaster

Read below for more details and reviews

Sandwich MakerBest FeatureCleaningBudgetRating
George Foreman GRP4842P3-in-1: GrillRemovable parts
(Dishwasher safe)
Premium4.9/5
Hamilton Beach 254905 minute cookingRemovable parts
(Dishwasher safe)
Premium4.7/5
Hamilton Beach 25478Audible tone timerRemovable parts
(Dishwasher safe)
Budget4.5/5
T-fal SW6100 EZ CleanInterchangeable platesRemovable plates
(Dishwasher safe)
Premium4.2/5
Proctor Silex 25401PUpright StorageWipeableBudget4/5
Proctor Silex 25408Upright StorageWipeable Budget3.5/5

#1 Pick: George Foreman GRP4842P Multi-Plate Evolve Sandwich Maker

If you’re looking for a grill that can do it all, the George Foreman GRP4842P is probably the best option for you. Not only is this George Foreman Grill backed by one of the most popular brands in grilling, but it also comes with quite a few advantages: removable plates, waffle plates, an adjustable cooking angle, and premium ceramic coating.

George Foreman GRP4842P

Time and Temperature Settings Provide Complete Control

In order to cook different things properly, you need to be able to control both time and temperature settings. Time settings will ensure that nothing is either overcooked or undercooked. Temperature settings range from 300 to 425 degrees, which is fairly typical or many grills. But where the George Foreman excels is that it also includes a special 500-degree setting. This produces the perfect sear, which is often necessary for things such as steak and chicken. It is searing that often separates restaurant-quality meals from home-made meals.

But where the George Foreman excels is that it also includes a special 500-degree setting. This produces the perfect sear, which is often necessary for things such as steak and chicken. It is searing that often separates restaurant-quality meals from home-made meals.

Use Either Ceramic Grilling Plates or Waffle Plates

The George Foreman comes with both ceramic grilling plates and waffle plates. Grilling plates can be used to grill a large variety of meats and vegetables — even meats as delicate as fish. But the George Foreman goes one step farther than traditional grills by including waffle plates. These optional waffle plates can be used to grill traditional waffles quickly. For breakfast, the George Foreman can be used to create traditional waffles and also to grill breakfast meats.

Adjust Cooking Angle Depending on Needs

For sandwiches, the George Foreman can be laid completely flat. This ensures that the sandwich is cooked very evenly throughout the bread’s surface. But for other types of foods, such as grilling meats, the cooking angle can be adjusted. Adjusting the angle can drain off oils and fats, providing a better sear on the surface and making the food healthier while not impacting taste.

The George Foreman GRP4842P is a premium model with many advanced features. But not everyone needs something this advanced — or expensive. For those who aren’t looking for something as versatile as the George Foreman GRP4842P, the Proctor Silex Sandwich Toaster or the Proctor Silex Sandwich Maker may be a better option.


#2 Pick: Hamilton Beach 25490 Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker

Make two breakfast sandwiches at once with the Hamilton Beach 25490 Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker. The Hamilton Beach 25490 is similar to the Hamilton Beach 25478, except for one important feature: it can make either one sandwich or two sandwiches at once.

Hamilton Beach 25490

Make Either One or Two Sandwiches

It’s very common that you may need to make breakfast for one or two people — or maybe a single sandwich just isn’t enough. The Hamilton Beach 25490 can make only a single sandwich or can make two different sandwiches at once. This can be especially useful if you have a large family. Because of the way the sandwich maker is made, you can even cook different types of filling in each.

Cook on Three Surfaces At Once

Though meat needs to be cooked before being placed in the sandwich maker, all of the fillings and the bread will be heated up at the same time. The exterior will be toasted while the interior will be heated through — this lets you cook eggs, vegetables, and melt cheese. The sandwiches can then be assembled when the entirety of the sandwich has been warmed. Once the sandwich has been fully cooked, a timer will go off.

Easy Breakfast Recipes Included

Though most people know how to make a traditional breakfast sandwich, that’s far from the only thing that the Hamilton Beach can do. The dual sandwich model of the Hamilton Beach sandwich maker comes with an easy breakfast recipe book, outlining different types of sandwiches that you can make. This book is also available for separate purchase and can also be used with the single sandwich maker.

The Hamilton Beach 25490 is an ideal and affordable breakfast sandwich machine for those who need to make multiple sandwiches at once. Of course, if you only need to make one at a time, the non-dual version is smaller and more affordable.

From grilled cheese sandwiches to crispy waffles, there are a lot of options available for fast sandwich makers. Proctor Silex makes the most affordable options for those who just want a fast and simple sandwich on the go — while Hamilton Beach offers the best in multi-layered breakfast sandwiches. If you want waffles as well as sandwiches, the T-fal is an affordable option and the George Foreman gives you premium features. Time to get cooking!


Budget Pick: Hamilton Beach 25478 breakfast Sandwich Maker

An all-in-one sandwich maker that produces restaurant-quality sandwiches, the Hamilton Beach 25478 Sandwich Maker can cook multiple layers of a sandwich at the same time. A total of three cooking surfaces lets this unique appliance multitask.

Hamilton Beach 25478

Make Muffins, Biscuits, and Bagels With Multiple Layers

Most of the other sandwich makers on this list are designed to create panini-style sandwiches that have toasted bread on the outside and warm, melted fillings on the inside. The Hamilton Beach 25478 is different. With three total trays — two outside and one in the middle — the Hamilton Beach can toast two slices of bread while also cooking the fillings. This makes it perfect to create a traditional breakfast sandwich: toast, meat, eggs, and toast. Eggs can be fried or scrambled and the meat can be any type. At the end, everything will be cooked through.

Easy Clean Up With Non-Stick Surfaces

Though there may be multiple trays, the Hamilton Beach isn’t difficult to clean. The trays can be removed from the appliance and then either rinsed off in the sink or thrown in the dishwasher — just as easy as cleaning a frying pan without the hassle of having to clean multiple items. The entire appliance fits together to be easily stored and measures only 7″ by 5″, so it can fit neatly into any kitchen.

Ready in Five Minutes With a Finishing Timer

Breakfast shouldn’t be hard. The Hamilton Beach sandwich maker will preheat in five minutes — about the time it takes to assemble ingredients and get them prepared. Once the items have been placed in to be cooked, the appliance will keep going until the finishing timer goes off. The finishing timer ensures that your sandwich and its fillings are never overcooked. From there, it’s a cake walk.

The Hamilton Beach 25478 is an appliance that is designed for a very specific purchase: making muffins and biscuit-style sandwiches. But there are some other options if you want something more versatile, such as the T-Fal waffle and sandwich maker which can prep waffles and sandwiches in no time.


#4 Pick: T-fal SW6100 EZ Non-Stick Sandwich Maker

Whether you want to make a sandwich or a waffle maker, the T-fal SW6100 EZ is a solid balance between features and simplicity. It’s available at an affordable price point, contains multiple dishwasher safe plates, and comes with over 986 positive customer reviews on Amazon.

T-Fal SW6100 EZ Clean

A Waffle Maker and Sandwich Maker in One

The T-Fal SW6100 EZ is designed to make both sandwiches and waffles. For sandwiches, the T-Fal creates a pocket within slices of bread that can be filled with any type of filling. Cheese, vegetables, and meats can all be used with these pocket-sandwiches. For waffles, the T-Fal produces very deep-pocketed waffles, which can then be filled with syrup, fruits, and jam. Either way, the resulting food is crispy and grilled to perfection.

Removable and Dishwasher Safe Plates

The plates on the T-Fal SW6100 EZ can be removed from the appliance and then tossed in the dishwasher, for an even easier cleanup. But because it’s a non-stick surface, it can also be wiped down instead with soap and cloth. The removable plates make it easier to transition from waffles to sandwiches, and the dishwasher-safe component is a unique advantage for this model.

Solid Quality With a 1-Year Warranty

The T-Fal is a little more expensive than some other sandwich makers, but it comes with a high-quality design that will last. A 1-year warranty ensures that the appliance will be free from manufacturing defect for at least twelve months, making the T-Fal an investment for those who want to purchase a reliable appliance. The T-Fal is heavier than many similar appliances, owing to superior materials and design.

The T-Fal SW6100 EZ is a good choice for those who want a solid appliance with extra features but very few frills. While it’s not the cheapest option on this list, it does offer a surprising amount of value.


#5 Pick: Proctor Silex 25401P Sandwich Maker

Similar in style and price to the Proctor Silex Sandwich Toaster, the Proctor Silex Sandwich Maker is a simple and perfect tool for quickly toasting whole sandwiches. It’s distinguished from the Sandwich Toaster in style; the Sandwich Toaster produces panini-style sandwiches, whereas the Sandwich Maker toasts whole sandwiches without cutting through them.

Proctor Silex 25401P

Make Grilled Sandwiches Faster

Perfect for a grilled cheese (or any other grilled sandwich), the Proctor Silex lets you avoid all of the mess usually associated with grilling. Setup, waiting, and cleaning times are all reduced: just put your sandwich in and wait. The Proctor Silex is able to alert you when it’s fully heated, so you can make a perfect sandwich quickly and without any guesswork. And because it’s easy to clean, you don’t have to do any extra dishes.

Locking Construction and Included Cord Wrap

For easy storage, the Sandwich Maker can lock into a standing position and includes a convenient cord wrap. The entirety of the sandwich maker will take up very little counter space, even when in use — and it will fit neatly into nearly any cupboard. The entirety of the machine is less than 10 inches by 10 inches and it’s less than 4 inches high, weighing only a little more than three pounds.

Usable Anywhere It Can Be Plugged In

With the Sandwich Maker, it doesn’t matter if you have a full kitchen available. The Sandwich Maker works anywhere there’s a power outlet — so that makes it perfect for temporary housing, dormitories, and other areas where full cooking functions may not be available. Because of the flat, easy-to-clean surface, it can also be washed and rinsed without the need for a sink.

If you want to be able to create a quick and simple sandwich, the Sandwich Maker should give you everything you need: it’s small, cheap, fast, and easy.


#6 Pick: Proctor Silex 25408 Sandwich toaster

One of the most affordable options available, the Proctor Silex 25408 Sandwich Toaster is a simple and easy tool specifically designed for toasting sandwiches. Unlike the George Foreman grill, it’s not ideal for meat and vegetables — but it doesn’t need to be. Instead, it’s a fantastic one-shot tool.

Proctor Silex 25408

Small, Affordable, and Easy to Use

Even if you don’t have a lot of corner space (or a big budget), the Proctor Silex is still a good choice. This sandwich toaster is small and compact, perfectly built for making small meals fast. The sandwich toaster can be stored upright, allowing it to be placed neatly anywhere, and it is one of the most affordable options available. If you just want to test out the utility of a sandwich toaster (or if you have simple needs), this is a perfect option.

Make Two Perfectly Grilled Sandwiches Fast

The Proctor Silex heats up fast, making two sandwiches in minutes. All users need to do is pop in their sandwiches and close the machine; two individually sliced, toasted sandwiches will be ready shortly. The Sandwich Toaster can be used for all types of sandwiches.

Use it for Omelets, French Toast, and Other Foods

Even though it’s simple, the Proctor Silex Sandwich Toaster can still be used to create other foods. Dip bread into egg batter to make French toast automatically — or fold eggs and cheese into it to make omelets. Anything that can be made by resting on a skillet can be made in the Proctor Silex.

Put Away Fast With Easy Clean Up

The Proctor Silex Sandwich Toaster both folds away for convenient storage and can be easily cleaned by being wiped down with soap and a damp cloth. The non-stick surface of the sandwich toaster means that there’s virtually no cleanup time. It also means that you’ll also get the perfect grill every time.

With the convenient size, easy cleanup, and fast use, the Proctor Silex is a faster and less complicated option than cooking food in a frying pan or in a skillet. The Proctor Silex Sandwich Toaster is designed to make grilled panini-style sandwiches two at a time. But maybe that’s not what you want — maybe you just want a traditional toasted sandwich without partitions. If so, you may instead want the Proctor Silex Sandwich Maker.


 

Leave a Comment: